An ex-colleague of mine told her boss she was going for a promotion. He said, “I don’t know what we’d do without you.”
When she told me about it a few days later, what struck me was how she felt afterwards. She didn’t walk away feeling valued; she walked away feeling guilty – as if wanting the next job meant she’d somehow let him down.
I’ve been thinking about it ever since, because I’d bet you have heard some version of it too. Maybe at the end of a manic enrolment week, or maybe after an inspection. Or maybe, when you mentioned the AP role that had just been advertised.
So what’s actually going on when someone says it?
When people in my teams told me they were going for promotion or they’d got the job, my reaction was pretty much always the same. “That’s fantastic.” I meant it every time. I was big on people growing and developing, and someone outgrowing their role felt like a sign I’d done my job properly.
Same news. Two very different answers.
I don’t know what was in her boss’s head, and I’m not going to guess. He may well have meant it as the biggest compliment he could think of. What I do know is that “that’s fantastic” was available to him, because it’s what I said, and plenty of other managers say it too. The guilt she carried away came from the answer she was given, not from anything she’d done wrong.
I’m fairly sure I’ve said “I don’t know what we’d do without you” myself, although I can’t pin down a single moment. The thank-you after a good inspection. The quiet word with someone who’d held a department together through a hard term. Kindly meant, every time. But if that’s the only thing someone ever hears from their manager, the message underneath is that they’re most useful exactly where they are.
If you’re the glue holding your department together
If you’re a Head of Department who’s been told she’s the glue holding everything together, I want you to notice that. Being indispensable in your current role is real recognition. It just isn’t the same as being seen as ready for the next one, and the two get muddled very easily. If you’re anything like the women I work with, you’ll take the compliment, feel the pull of loyalty, and quietly decide now isn’t the right time.
So the next time someone tells you they don’t know what they’d do without you, try hearing it for what it is:
Neither of those is a reason to stay put. And feeling guilty about wanting more doesn’t mean the wanting is wrong. Usually it just means you care about the people around you. You can care about them and still go.
They’ll work out what to do without you; they always do.
What were you told when you said you were going for the promotion? Or what do you wish someone had said instead?
If the guilt has you telling yourself now isn’t the right time, that reason probably sounds very sensible. I wrote about why it so often isn’t in Fear Dressed Up as Logic: Why You Keep Putting Off Senior Leadership


